Why Standards-Based Teaching Has Failed to Raise Reading Achievement

Perennial cornflower and pollinator.

Why Standards-Based Teaching Has Failed to Raise Reading Achievement

            Standards-based educational reform goes back to the early 1990s.

Since then, test scores have see-sawed a bit, but for the most part we are doing about as well

as we’ve been doing since 1970 (when we first started collecting national reading data).

            That means standards-based reform has not led to higher achievement. Establishing educational goals and aligning teaching to those goals to ensure kids succeed has not happened.

            Diane Ravitch, and others who don’t spend much time in schools, claim to know why standards have failed. They believe that if teachers were just left to their own devices,

American kids would excel in school.

            Unlike them, I’ve spent much time in classrooms and working with kids

over the past four decades or so…as teacher, lunch room supervisor, park supervisor,

student teacher, tutor, researcher, remediator, teacher educator, observer, evaluator,

school administrator, textbook author, test designer, parent, grandparent, and uncle.

            My take on the problem is different, but I do agree that it is a problem.

            I have come to believe that standards-based reform will NEVER work unless educators

come to understand the idea of standards-based teaching, something that has not happened

during the past 25 years.

            To illustrate my point, I received the following two notes from teachers last week:

I teach 4th grade in a Daily 5/Cafe school. We have NO curriculum or requirements other than...

2 mini lessons, conferring individually and maintaining strategy groups with students.

Do you have any advice or thoughts on the organizing and planning within these four areas? 

I am working on a district committee that is developing a universal literacy framework

for our elementary schools. One of the recommended components is shared reading,

which is not currently a formalized daily practice at our highest-achieving schools.

Is there an argument, based on research, for this component to be mandated for all classrooms

as part of an excellent literacy program? The research that I have found seems to mainly focus

on pre-schoolers. 

            What sense do I make of these queries? They reveal that their schools are dedicated

to promoting particular activities and practices—not to teaching children.

There are particular activities these principals and teachers want to see in classrooms, and they

are not particular focused on what they are supposed to be engaged in: teaching children to read.

            Instead of focusing like-a-laser on what they want kids to know, to be able to do, to be,

they are promoting favorite classroom activities. Instead of thinking about how to get kids

to a particular outcome, they are wondering if they can somehow align the required activities

with useful outcomes. It would be like a surgeon deciding what kind of surgery

he wanted to conduct and then hoping to stretch it to the patient’s needs

(“Sorry Mr. Jones. I know you have prostate cancer, but I like to do hysterectomies.”)

            Until we actually focus on teaching the standards—that is, until we decide that our job

is to ensure that kids learn what we have agreed to teach them—then it will continue to look like

our kids are failing. (And, no, “test prep” is not teaching to our standards, it is just one more example of educators focusing on particular activities rather than on reaching particular outcomes).

 Shanahan on Literacy http://www.shanahanonliteracy.com/

Introduction to Turbo Charged Reading YouTube

A practical overview of Turbo Charged Reading YouTube 

How to choose a book. A Turbo Charged Reading YouTube

Emotions when Turbo Charged Reading YouTube

Advanced Reading Skills Perhaps you’d like to join my FaceBook group ?

www.facebook.com/mreenhunt

www.pinterest.com/mreenhunt

Perhaps you’d like to check out my sister blogs:

www.innermindworking.blogspot.com         gives many ways for you to work with the stresses of life

www.ourinnerminds.blogspot.com               which takes advantage of the experience and expertise of others.

www.happyartaccidents.blogspot.com         just for fun.

To quote the Dr Seuss himself, “The more that you read, the more things you will know.

The more that you learn; the more places you'll go.”